This article aims to suggest a different interpretation of Aeschylus’ Choephoroi 273-5. The terms and expressions used here and in many other sections of the Oresteia may have reminded the Athenian audience of the contemporary homicide laws and legal procedures, where the archaic ethics of revenge was now ‘institutionalised’ and handled by the polis’ authority. Moreover, these lines seem to allude to a well-known pre-legal practice whereby the violent retaliation underlying revenge could be extinguished if the offender paid a compensation (ποινή) accepted by the family of the victim. The results of this study will allow, first, to highlight some linguistic intersections and analogies between tragedy and oratory when referring specifically to the notions of justice, guilt, and responsibility in homicide cases. Secondly, the paper will propose an alternative translation for the ambiguous ἀποχρημάτοισι ζημίαις (Ch. 273), after examining the interpretations and hypotheses of leading scholars of this play. Finally, I will try to determine the synonymy of ζημία and ποινή from the perspective of Athenian law, since both these terms might express a variety of related concepts (revenge, money-fine, penalty, and compensation) all inherent in the offender’s punishment and the resulting satisfaction of the prosecutors’ claims for justice.

"Becoming as savage as a bull because of penalties not to be paid with money”: Orestes’ Revenge and the Ethics of Retaliatory Violence

Luca Fiamingo
2023-01-01

Abstract

This article aims to suggest a different interpretation of Aeschylus’ Choephoroi 273-5. The terms and expressions used here and in many other sections of the Oresteia may have reminded the Athenian audience of the contemporary homicide laws and legal procedures, where the archaic ethics of revenge was now ‘institutionalised’ and handled by the polis’ authority. Moreover, these lines seem to allude to a well-known pre-legal practice whereby the violent retaliation underlying revenge could be extinguished if the offender paid a compensation (ποινή) accepted by the family of the victim. The results of this study will allow, first, to highlight some linguistic intersections and analogies between tragedy and oratory when referring specifically to the notions of justice, guilt, and responsibility in homicide cases. Secondly, the paper will propose an alternative translation for the ambiguous ἀποχρημάτοισι ζημίαις (Ch. 273), after examining the interpretations and hypotheses of leading scholars of this play. Finally, I will try to determine the synonymy of ζημία and ποινή from the perspective of Athenian law, since both these terms might express a variety of related concepts (revenge, money-fine, penalty, and compensation) all inherent in the offender’s punishment and the resulting satisfaction of the prosecutors’ claims for justice.
2023
Greek tragedy; Aeschylus; Oresteia; ancient Greek law; revenge; retaliation; retributive justice
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Becoming_as_savage_as_a_bull_because_of.pdf

accesso aperto

Licenza: Copyright dell'editore
Dimensione 373.12 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
373.12 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11562/1121518
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact