This paper wishes to discuss whether present-day autocrats show distinctively Nietzschean characteristics or not. Achieving that implies a discussion of Nietzsche’s admiration of certain strongmen in history, and, overall, on the nature of truly Nietzschean rulers: as it turns out, they are all aristocrats. Being an aristocrat, for Nietzsche, not necessarily implies belonging to a social elite or hierarchy, but rather accepting agon as selbst-Bildung, displaying a solid rule over oneself, and striving to achieve self-realization as the wholeness of the spiritual and the animal. These characteristics put Nietzsche’s aristocrats against tyrannical rulers, who are rather described as men who, like Luther and especially Socrates, exert control over themselves, and nurtur their will to power, by over-emphasizing a single characteristic (faith and reason, respectively) over the rest of the human whole. In conclusion, present-day autocrats seem to have much more in common with these essentially sick tyrannical natures than with true aristocratic rulers; however, this does not allow us to rule Nietzschean features in them out entirely.
Aristocrats and Tyrants. Nietzschean Rulers versus Today’s Autocrats
Chiurco
2023-01-01
Abstract
This paper wishes to discuss whether present-day autocrats show distinctively Nietzschean characteristics or not. Achieving that implies a discussion of Nietzsche’s admiration of certain strongmen in history, and, overall, on the nature of truly Nietzschean rulers: as it turns out, they are all aristocrats. Being an aristocrat, for Nietzsche, not necessarily implies belonging to a social elite or hierarchy, but rather accepting agon as selbst-Bildung, displaying a solid rule over oneself, and striving to achieve self-realization as the wholeness of the spiritual and the animal. These characteristics put Nietzsche’s aristocrats against tyrannical rulers, who are rather described as men who, like Luther and especially Socrates, exert control over themselves, and nurtur their will to power, by over-emphasizing a single characteristic (faith and reason, respectively) over the rest of the human whole. In conclusion, present-day autocrats seem to have much more in common with these essentially sick tyrannical natures than with true aristocratic rulers; however, this does not allow us to rule Nietzschean features in them out entirely.File | Dimensione | Formato | |
---|---|---|---|
A40. Aristocrats & Tyrants.pdf
solo utenti autorizzati
Tipologia:
Versione dell'editore
Licenza:
Copyright dell'editore
Dimensione
2.56 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.56 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri Richiedi una copia |
I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.